My Favorite Audiobooks, Round Two: 11 More Five-Star Listens

Share the book love!

Here are 11 audiobooks worth adding to your queue right now. Retellings, a courtroom thriller, family sagas — each a five-star story with narration that’s impossible to pause.

No matter how selective I tried to be, one list was never going to cover it. And why should it? I’m not here to gatekeep great books, so here are 11 more titles that made my Favorite Audiobooks of All Time list.

If you missed the first roundup, that’s where I break down what separates a good audiobook from a five-star one: the narrator (or even better, the cast of narrators), and the production choices that turn a story into an experience. It also includes 12 of my favorites, from a time-traveling Scottish tale to a WWII survival story that had my husband hiding in the garage for “just one more chapter.” Read that first post here.

This round brings a few retellings, a courtroom thriller, a memoir that’ll make you grateful for modern medicine, and a family saga or two that just might break you a little.

The standard’s the same as last time: a great story, and an even better listen. Here are 11 more audiobooks that nailed it.

11 Audiobooks That Deserve a Spot on Your Playlist

1. James by Percival Everett

One of my top reads of 2025, this book was exceptional on audio. A retelling of Huckleberry Finn from Jim’s perspective — yes, it’s every bit as sharp and compelling as that premise sounds.

2. Black Cake by Charmaine Wilkerson

A family story spanning two generations, gorgeously read by Lynette R. Freeman and Simone McIntyre. The portraits of love lost and found, family torn apart, and a mother’s endless devotion were vivid, and they still haven’t faded. (And yes, now I want to make a black cake. If I ever do, I’ll come back and report on that, too.)

3. The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society by Mary Ann Shaffer

This is the book that planted the seed for Words On Location, my whole “book + travel” obsession. After listening to this story, I knew I had to visit the island of Guernsey. The trip was derailed by the pandemic, but it’s still on my bucket list. In the meantime, a transportive multi-cast narration (by Paul Boehmer, Susan Duerden, Rosalyn Landor, John Lee, and Juliet Mills) gets me most of the way there.

4. The Women by Kristin Hannah

Julia Whelan shows up again on one of my lists, and for good reason. The range of emotion her voice carries is iconic. If you are one of the handful of people who haven’t read this one yet, consider this one on audio. I promise you won’t regret it.

If The Women is on your or your book club’s radar, I’ve created a done-for-you book club kit that has everything you need, from discussion questions to activities to literary field trips (it’s pay-what-you-want, even free).

5. This Story Might Save Your Life by Tiffany Crum

Possibly the best audiobook I’ve listened to this year. Julia Whelan (told you she’d be back) and Sean Patrick Hopkins are both excellent, but what really sets this one apart is the production. The audio effects are some of the best I’ve heard. An easy pick for my all-time list.

Did You Know?

The Shop offers pay-what-you-want pricing (yes, that includes free) for complete book club kits and other bookish resources. See what is new here.

6. Call the Midwife by Jennifer Worth

Can a book about the lives of midwives working in some of the poorest communities in London’s East End be captivating? Absolutely — as long as it’s written by Jennifer Worth and read by Nicola Barber! I listened to the entire first book in a single day while taking down Christmas decorations, and I was surprisingly sad when it ended. Good thing there are more in the series.

7. Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt

This book is a five-star read on the page, but Marin Ireland (yes, her again, she’s that good) takes it up another level entirely. Anyone who can make an octopus feel like a fully realized character has serious skills.

8. Lady Tremaine by Rachel Hochhauser

A reimagining of the Cinderella story from the stepmother’s point of view, and I loved every minute of it, largely thanks to Bessie Carter. I’m the type of listener who speeds up nearly every audiobook I hit play on — except hers. Ms. Carter’s voice deserves every minute of any book she narrates.

Side Note: This book will give you much to discuss and would make a fantastic book club pick.

If you’re enjoying this list, I’d love for you to join my free reader community, the Words On Location Book Club. We share recommendations like these all the time, host online discussions, and enjoy talking about books with people who get it. You’re welcome anytime.

9. Judge Stone by James Patterson & Viola Davis

Written and read by Viola Davis in her own distinctive voice, this one is as much a treat for the ears as it is for the mind. A great narrator can shape both the setting and the feel of the story, and Ms. Davis does exactly that. Her pacing is slow and deliberate, so you can safely bump up the playback speed without losing a thing.

10. The Dutch House by Ann Patchett

An Ann Patchett story narrated by Tom Hanks? Literary fiction doesn’t get much better than that pairing. I listened to this book years ago, and what I remember even more than the plot is how the listening experience itself made me feel.

11. Life, & Death, & Giants by Ron Rindo

The multicast narration is what makes this one sing. It was an astonishing story, but the different points of view voiced with such distinct personalities upped the emotional ante. Christina Moore, Johnny Heller, Roger Wayne, and Will Damron made this book an auditory hit. 

And that’s round two — 23 audiobooks down, and I promise I’m not done yet. If you missed the first batch, go back and start there for some great stories and even better storytelling, including the one I recommend to everyone who asks where they should start with audiobooks. More favorites coming soon!

Let’s Keep the Audiobook Conversation Going

Did I miss your favorite audiobook? I’d love to hear about it! Drop it in the comments or come share it in the Words On Location Book Club. We’re always swapping recommendations and sharing new bookish discoveries.

Where do you find your audiobooks? My favorite resource is my local library (Libby is my best friend!). I’m also an affiliate for Libro.FM, an audiobook retailer that gives back. When you buy your audiobooks from Libro.FM, a portion of the price supports local bookstores or bookish affiliates like me (you can choose the independent bookstore or affiliate you’d like to support 🙂).

Happy reading, friends. May your next audiobook be a perfect listening experience.


Gain access to our Free Book Lover’s Library

Enter your email to gain instant access

What you’ll find inside our Freebie Library

  • Book club kits for many popular books
  • Challenges, guides, & resources to curate and organize your literary lifestyle — with new bookish delights added regularly
  • Invitations to special events — online book club discussions, BYOB (Bring Your Own Book) Lit Chats, special guest talks, & more — exclusively for our community members

“Holy smokes! You turn out incredible quality with your content. Bookshops should hire you to make stuff like this for them.” — Katy Sloop Roberts, Author

“Wow!!!! I absolutely love this!!! As a writer myself, I often struggle to find resources like the ones you have added to your website, and I just wanted to thank you for it. I truly, honestly, and wholeheartedly appreciate it.” — JR, Author


Pin this to your bookish boards!


Share the book love!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *